Scottish craft beer producer Brewdog is toasting its recent victory over the Elvis Presley Estate (the Estate) after winning its appeal to register the trade mark Brewdog Elvis Juice (the Mark).
The application was initially refused by the UK Intellectual Property Office (UKIPO) in June 2017 based on the Estate’s prior registered trademarks, sparking a fightback from the owners, who even changed their own names by deed poll to Elvis, in a bid to strengthen their case.
So how did Brewdog win a trade mark battle against the King of Rock n’ Roll?
For trade mark disputes such as this, semantics can play a key role. The UKIPO compares the marks in question and the association an average consumer would make between the mark applied for and the existing mark(s).
In particular, it looks at the likelihood of a consumer being confused and believing (in this case) that the Mark – Brewdog Elvis Juice – signifies that products sold under it come from, are officially endorsed by or linked with the owner of a third party existing trade mark – the mark ‘Elvis’ owned by the Estate.
The UKIPO originally decided in the Estate’s favour and concluded that there was a likelihood that the Mark would confuse the average consumer. Elvis was considered to be the prominent part of the mark and the public would associate it with Elvis Presley.
There is only one Brewdog. The same cannot be said for Elvis.
However, one of the main reasons for Brewdog’s victory upon appeal is that Brewdog itself is an unusual name, invented by the company’s founders. The company has worked hard to establish and promote what is now, a well-known international brand.
In contrast to the original decision, the Appointed Person (AP), who heard the appeal, considered Brewdog to be at least as well-known, if not more so than Elvis, (as opposed to the combination Elvis Presley). This meant that customers would not necessarily make a connection to the Elvis Presley when they saw the name Elvis used in the Brewdog Elvis Juice combination.
According to the AP there was a likelihood that Brewdog would be the more memorable and distinctive part of the Mark. Use of it as an invented and unusual word – and as the first part of “Brewdog Elvis Juice” – would mean that it was sufficiently different to the mark Elvis to avoid any confusion
The AP stated: “The word Brewdog, which evokes concepts of dogs brewing and juice….., alludes to a liquid, so Brewdog Elvis Juice has numerous concepts (names dogs brewing and liquids) conjured in the mind , whereas Elvis is just a name…..as none of the elements dominate, there is a low level of conceptual similarity between the marks.”
In contrast, Elvis Juice, another mark Brewdog had applied for, was deemed too similar to Elvis and the appeal was refused, on the basis that the average consumer would think Elvis Juice and beer marketed under the Elvis mark would come from the same source.
On the whole this seems a sensible decision. The imaginative and distinctive quality of the brand Brewdog, combined with its reach , means that there is little doubt that customers who see it as the first part of a mark are likely to make the connection with the correct source. There is – thanks in large part to Brewdog’s efforts in protecting its exclusive rights to its name as a brand – only one Brewdog. The same cannot be said for Elvis.
However, it does not mean that Brewdog’s owners are now free to market their Elvis Juice product in whatever manner they wish. They should not, for instance, use the word Elvis alone, or with Juice, separately to the word Brewdog in promotional material. This avoids possible future disputes over infringement of the Elvis – or indeed Elvis Presley – marks.
Choosing a product or business trade mark can be a complex and risky business, particularly when opting for one similar in wording or presentation to another existing, well-known mark or brand.
It is vitally important to carry out proper due diligence to ascertain infringement risk and clear the way to use and register the preferred mark before launch, or indeed before investing significant resources in developing it as a brand.
With this in mind, advice from IP legal professionals can be invaluable and ideally should be sought at the earliest opportunity to save what can be significant costs and embarrassment down the line.
Gill Grassie is Head of IP Dispute Resolution at Brodies LLP.
Related posts
Interviews
Comment
Why innovation and marketing are the perfect partners to make changes that matter
With the rapid evolution of traditional marketing and the appearance of digital marketing, technology and innovation has become part of any marketer’s life without the need of working for a…
Transitioning to a four-day week – CEO’s vow to strike a healthier balance in the workplace
I came to Scotland nearly 20 years ago from Ireland, with no contacts but a lot of determination. While Ireland will always be my home, Scotland has given me amazing…
Women Lead: The female-led company championing intuitive working
Over the last two years, the pandemic forced a shift to more remote and flexible working practices. Whilst we might be seeing a “return to normal”, some companies are choosing…
Women Lead: My passion for young people to consider a career in digital
Twenty years ago, I stumbled across my career in digital marketing almost by accident. It was during my honours degree in marketing at Glasgow Caledonian University. I was on work…
Women Lead: Inclusive Silicon Valley cohort gives hope to entrepreneurs from diverse backgrounds
Things are happening on the Scottish tech scene. Big and small initiatives are creating a fantastic ripple effect on the sector, bottom up and top down, thanks to the recommendations…
Women Lead: The story of an entrepreneurial scientist
I first arrived in Scotland over 20 years ago. I had £75 in my wallet and a scholarship offer to do a PhD at the University of Edinburgh. Sometimes I…
Please mind the gap… or healthcare may fall
Imagine sharing a lengthy train journey with others. From beginning to end, imagine how often you might hear ‘mind the gap’ messages about embarking and disembarking safely. Picture how navigating…
Women Lead: My journey from Dragons’ Den to Silicon Valley
Following her appearance on Dragons’ Den, Sheila Hogan, serial entrepreneur, founder and chief executive of digital legacy vault, Biscuit Tin, shares her experience of her time in the Den and…